Is Social Media Marketing A Waste Of Time?

Is Social Media Marketing A Waste Of Time?

With all the hype that surrounds “social media marketing”, you’d imagine it was a marketing cure-all.

Many self proclaimed social media “gurus” would have you believe that social media is the future of all marketing and that if you’re not dedicating all or most of your marketing resources to social media, you’re a luddite who’ll soon be out of business.

Of course like most hype, there’s a need to keep a level head in order to separate fact from fiction.

Before I’m labelled as being against social media, let me set the record straight. I’ve used social media in multiple businesses and continue to use it on a regular basis.

However because there’s so much hype that surrounds social media, I want to put it in perspective for you and help you see where it fits into an overall marketing strategy.

It’s A Media

A successful marketing campaign has to get three vital elements right:

  • Message – The marketing message or offer you send
  • Market – The target market you send your message to
  • Media – The media you use to send your message to your target market e.g. radio, direct mail, telemarketing, TV etc.

You need to hit all three of these to have a successful campaign. You need to send the right message to the right target market, through the right media channel.

Failing at any one of these three elements will likely cause your marketing campaign to fail.

Understanding this framework helps put things in context. Social media, by definition is a media – it’s not a strategy.

The time tested fundamentals of marketing don’t suddenly change just because a new media comes along.

Is It The Right Media For Your Business?

The next thing to ask – is it the right media for your business?

Remember of the three things we need to get right for a successful campaign, media is one of them.

Every type of media has it’s idiosyncrasies and social media is no exception. Here are some of the things you need to be aware of when it comes to social media.

Firstly it’s not the ideal selling environment. I like to think of social media as a social gathering or party.

We’ve all been to gatherings where someone, perhaps a family member or friend has been bitten by the multi-level marketing bug. You know where they start spruiking the health benefits of the latest pills or potions and try to sell or recruit others to sell.

It makes everyone uncomfortable because it feels pushy and feels like an inappropriate time to be making or receiving a sales pitch.

Social media is exactly the same. Overt selling and constant pitching of offers is generally considered poor behaviour on social networks and can result in repelling people from your business rather than attracting them.

However just like a real life social gathering, social media is a great place to create and extend relationships which can later turn into something commercial if there’s a good fit.

One of the most valuable things I see in social media is being able to gauge customer emotions toward your business and engage with vocal customers who offer either praise or complaints in a public forum.

A side benefit of this is social proof. Being accessible, responding to criticism or praise and engaging with your customers builds social proof and makes prospects and customers feel like they are dealing with humans rather than a faceless corporation. Remember people buy from people.

Two Social Media Traps To Beware Of

There are two potential traps with social media.

Firstly it can be a time suck.

Feeling like you have to respond to every inane comment can be draining and it can suck time away from marketing tasks that can give you a far better return on time and money invested.

It’s important to be disciplined with your use of social media. Just like you wouldn’t let your employees stand around and chit chat all day, you can’t let yourself or them get carried away with the online equivalent.

Secondly there’s the question of ownership. Your social media page and profile is actually the property of the social network. So spending huge amounts of time and money building up a profile and audience on these networks ends up building up their assets rather than your own.

My preference as much as possible is to build and own my own marketing assets such as websites, blogs, email lists etc. I then use social media simply as a way to drive traffic to these marketing assets.

This way, my time and effort goes into renovating my own “house” rather than that of a landlord who can kick me out at any time.

A classic example of why you want to do this is Facebook’s change of policy on business pages.

Previously if people “Liked” your business’s Facebook page you could freely reach this entire audience for free. So businesses spent a lot of time, money and effort getting people to “Like” them on their Facebook page.

Now Facebook requires you to pay them each time you want to send a message to your entire audience, otherwise it only allows you to reach a small percentage. For those who spent huge resources on building up a Facebook audience only to have the rug pulled out from under them, this came as a huge blow.

This is one of the reasons why personally I’d prefer to have 1000 people on my own email list than 10,000 people who “Like” my Facebook page.

As always with any marketing strategy it’s vitally important to find out where your prospects “hangout” and use the appropriate media to get your message through to them. Social media may or may not be one of those places they hang out.

How are you using or how do you plan to use social media in your marketing? I’d love to hear more from you in the comments section below.

Connect with Allan Dib on Google+


  • Social Media Marketing

    Reply Reply December 21, 2012

    Very helpful content for Social Media Marketing. It helps new and established businesses to increase their captive audience. Many Many Thanks for share with us.

  • Shaleen Shah

    Reply Reply December 27, 2012

    I think that social media should not be mixed with the term ‘marketing’ in the first place. Because social media is a tool to communicate – it’s not selling media. I like that you raise the question on ownership, because these 3rd party sites can always change its policies. I guess, your blog should be your home base; something you have total control of. The problem with marketing online is that people and brands are pressured to keep up with vanity metrics so they go on purchasing fake followers, fans, friends.. and then, they complain that no one is converting? My lips are sealed.

  • Dave Zwicker

    Reply Reply January 1, 2013

    “If you have more Money than brains, you should focus on Outbound Marketing. If you have more Brains than money, you should focus on Inbound Marketing.” – Guy Kawasaki

    I think the author makes a great case for applying “brains” when leveraging social media platforms for inbound marketing purposes. SMM can be an enormous exercise in futility without the right kind of compelling content, a well-defined distribution strategy and, of course, relentless (daily) execution. Thanks for the post – very meaningful insights.

  • Dean Cassidy

    Reply Reply June 4, 2014

    Fantastic article and spot on about the need to ensure that you get a good return on investment.

  • Sorin

    Reply Reply April 15, 2015

    Fantastic article.
    Many just do things because they just heard that it must be done. I’ve been saying for years to use Facebook in order to channel traffic to your website and not the other way around.
    Another social media surprises are sure to come in the near future as the number of users continues to grow and grow.
    Thanks again for the insights.

Leave A Response

* Denotes Required Field